Bodhi Path Press translations

Is anyone familiar with something called Bodhi Path Press?

They have quite a few books on Amazon. The Majjhima Nikaya translation appears to be a slight adaptation of Bhante @Sujato’s translation. We can date it roughly based on “what the hell Kali” in MN 21. (which is now ‘Oi wench, Kāḷī!’)

The Jataka translation is, unsurprisingly, Cowel’s edition. The Digha Nikaya is Bhante Sujato’s from around 2019 (you can get some old editions here.)

They appeare to be created through the (self publishing?) agency grapevineindia.com. Otherwise I can find nothing about Bodhi Path Press online.

The text has signs of “Hindi-ization”:

Ukkaṭṭhā → Ukkatth
Brahmā → Brahm
Sāriputta → Sirputta

I guess one of the consequences of having good public domain translations in the world is that we will end up with these “ghost” translations floating around without any sense of their origin.

7 Likes

That is perhaps the reason why the DPD is using a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

5 Likes

I understand why Bhante @Sujato and many good monks prefer CC0, but as Ven @sabbamitta said, there is a good reason why some dhamma books or websites prefer Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

3 Likes

I like Michael Leunig’s decision: FAQ - Leunig

Copyright

Non-commercial

If your project is being produced, written, projected or made within an educational or community setting, you may reproduce, print or project a Leunig cartoon, poem or written excerpt free of charge. You don’t need permission if there is no profit being made from your project. You may also use a cartoon, poem or written excerpt on a personal blog, or social media page as long as it is credited. You can drag and drop web-sized cartoons from the cartoon gallery, or the recent cartoons page. Please use the contact form if you cannot find the cartoon you are looking for.

Please credit all cartoons as follows: Image courtesy of Michael Leunig

Commercial

If you wish to reproduce a Leunig cartoon or poem within a commercial project or publication, please email his office with details and we can provide you with high resolution files. There is a small royalty fee applicable.

2 Likes

Report it to Amazon as I think books published on Kindle cannot be directly lifted from the Public Domain.

I thought this was a feature and not a bug?

It looks like they have made at least some changes. I looked at the policy and it appears to me (for this and other reasons) that it doesn’t violate the policy. Any way, I’m not that concerned.

My issue wasn’t that the PD translations are being used in different ways, just that it makes it easier to have translations floating around where we don’t know anything about who created it. Obviously there is no reason someone couldn’t anonymously publish a new translation. It’s just far more likely with a PD version.

1 Like