There is a Buddhist story about a Brahmin named Māgandiya who wanted to give his beautiful daughter to the Buddha as a wife.
In response, the Buddha is said to him ( Snp 4.9) :
“Even when I saw the sirens Craving, Malignancy, and Lust,
I had no desire for sex.
What is this body full of piss and shit?
I wouldn’t even want to touch it with my foot.”
I must admit that these words raise some doubts in me. They sound as if the Buddha felt aversion, or even disgust, toward the human body as such.
Meanwhile, my understanding of Buddhist teachings is that an arahant, as a fully liberated being, should experience neither attachment and desire nor aversion. So why did the Buddha use words that could be interpreted as an expression of disgust? Especially since, in other passages, he himself emphasized the importance of proper speech, including gentleness and kindness.
Can we therefore conclude that the Buddha acted contrary to the principles he himself taught?
Huh; I don’t read it that way at all. I see the Buddha as one completely dis-illusioned about bodies, free from lust and aversion and isn’t denigrating anyone or anything but merely saying that the body is not intrinsically beautiful or something to indulge in. Seeing a body in its totality instead of its surface doesn’t have to involve hatred or aversion. We all know that a text message can be interpreted in many ways by just seeing the words without knowing intention, hearing the tone of voice or nonverbal cues.
There’s plenty of ways to practise the asubha, reflection on the unattractiveness. For those not used to it, of course aversion, disgust can and will arise. Eventually, one trains to become equanimious to it, and temporary disgust as antidote to lust when needed.
The parents of that lady has great pride in the lady’s beauty. This strong wording I think is more for the benefit of the parents, so that lust can be removed from their minds. And indeed they become non returners.
For the enlightened ones, there’s also choices. Given the choice of stepping between a road which is dirtied by cow dung, still wet Vs one that is not, it’s natural to choose the cleaner road, given no obstacles.
He is simply stating facts: the body contains urine and feces (see Kp 3); he didn’t have any desire to have sex; he didn’t have any desire to touch a body even with his foot. Where is the aversion?
People often assume the Buddha was feeling aversion when he stated facts that we would consider “socially unacceptable”. Perhaps because we like to pretend like the body is beautiful and desirable, because we can’t imagine saying something that would offend people by challenging their world view, or because we personally would only say something unpleasant out of aversion, we might project our reactions onto him. It’s difficult for us to understand the mind of an arahant (or really anyone else for that matter) to know for certain what they are thinking or feeling:
A realized one is freed from reckoning in terms of consciousness. They’re deep, immeasurable, and hard to fathom, like the ocean. (MN 72)
Right Speech actually does include saying things that are not endearing, as long as they meet the other criteria:
The Realized One knows the right time to speak so as to explain what he knows to be true, correct, and beneficial, but which is disliked by others. (MN 58)
The Buddha had the ability to comprehend peoples’ minds (stated in multiple suttas, such as MN 119), and there are so many instances of people becoming awakened after a single conversation with him, that it seems clear to me that he uses that knowledge to know the right thing to say to the right person at the right time. For example, in SN 22.87, he says, in reference to himself, “Enough, Vakkali! Why would you want to see this rotting body?" (similar type of language to the sutta you asked about), spoke a few more phrases of Dhamma to him, and the next day, the monk attained arahantship. Everyone reacts differently to speech based on their unique conditioning, so what may seem harsh or unpleasant to someone may be eye-opening or helpful to another.
I think when we practice and start to see any kind of results within ourselves, even if it’s not any meditative prowess or noble attainments - it could be simply realizing that when we follow the ethical guidelines we feel blameless and thus joyful, etc. - we gain more faith in the Buddha and trust that he was truly free from greed, hatred, and delusion. And with that faith, if we see something (in an EBT at least, which is most likely to be the true words of the historic Buddha) that on the surface seems to contradict this fact or seem impossible, we can consider that maybe we just haven’t gotten to a point in our practice to truly understand - and in addition to asking the community for clarification, it can prompt us to undertake a critical investigation of the Dhamma (why do I think this?, are there alternatives I’m not considering?, is this supported by other suttas?, etc.) which can be really helpful for our personal growth; after all, the Buddha lists “Investigation of Dhamma” as one of the 7 factors of enlightenment (SN 46.1).
Thank you very much for all your responses; they helped set in motion an internal process that had been brewing within me but couldn’t quite find expression. From my perspective, what the Buddha said in this specific situation and context was simply very harsh—certainly not gentle—and I don’t want to pretend otherwise. As the comments point out, it triggered a chain reaction that ultimately led to a great deal of suffering. I don’t blame the Buddha for this, though I believe it could have been handled better—or perhaps it simply couldn’t have been handled any other way.
I also genuinely believe that the Buddha’s intentions were good, but good intentions do not always yield good results for everyone. One might argue that it’s difficult to judge the situation as a whole because we don’t know the long-term karmic consequences, but to me, that feels a bit like intellectual laziness.
There are other instances where the Buddha called monks “fools” in the presence of others; to me, that constitutes a lack of respect, and I find it difficult to suppress or deny what I think and feel.
It has only just dawned on me what the core of the issue I’ve been grappling with actually is: could the Awakened Siddhartha Gautama have made mistakes? My personal opinion is that yes, he could have. Like any human being—even one who is enlightened—he was capable of making mistakes. And, for me, that is perfectly fine.
I would rather admit to myself that there are aspects of Buddhism I don’t entirely like, rather than deny my own feelings—though perhaps my perspective will change in a few years. In any case, this in no way diminishes how much I value Buddhism.
I will continue to take my own small steps in my Buddhist practice. Stumbling at every turn. But perhaps I’ll be a bit more understanding with myself now.
well mate. The Buddha, being an arhant and fully enlightened, don’t feel such disgust or anything. But for such situations, his priority is who would get liberated from his speech. It’s noted that there are different types of speech such as:
Right [correct] and beneficial and people like it.
Right [correct] and beneficial but people don’t like it.
Right and not beneficial but people like it.
Right and not beneficial and people don’t like it.
Lie and beneficial and people like it.
lie and beneficial and people don’t like it.
Lie and not beneficial but people like it.
lie and not beneficial and people also don’t like it.
It’s said that the Buddha only speak of the first two. In this scenario, what he said was: Right [correct] and beneficial but people don’t [more like may not] like it. What he said was fully valid. If you look at the rupa deep, it’s just nothing to want about. And the two listeners parents had habits of practising that asuba meditation in past lives. So, the Buddha by saying that so triggerred their past habits and therefore, they became anagami magga people if I remember correctly.
Good intentions always lead to good results, for everyone who is keeping that intention. Not for everyone in the world, if that is what you are saying. That is impossible. The Buddha knows the long-term karmic consequences of any action, although he himself does not create kamma anymore. Your reaction is genuine and obviously should not be disregarded. However, as other point out, it may be a good exercise to question why did I have this reaction? Why this statement provoke such a reaction in me? Not in a way to convince yourself that you are wrong by reacting like that (nor right), but really to investigate yourself. What we call harsh and rude today may certainly have changed after more than two thousand years ago, and by the context of the story, the person did not got offended, but you did. What is behind that? What ideas and assumptions are behind that? This kind of questioning should be done as much as possible for agreeable and disagreeable things that appear in our lives.
This depends on mistakes regarding what? His teachings? Impossible. The way of treating people? Depends on what you call mistakes. Speaking with intention to harm, humiliate etc.? Impossible. To make a person become offended with what he is saying? Yes, sure. People will be offended for their reasons, not even a Buddha can know everything. At one time the Buddha was hearing a big noise from the monks and he rebuked them very harshly and dismissed them.
(After all, no matter the size of a group of monks, it should not be noise at all. One day a king was heading to the Buddha’s company by recommendation of his subject and he thought that he was walking to his death, because it was so very silent, how come the Buddha had thousands of disciples if I’m hearing nothing at all?)
Turns out the monks were novice, didn’t know any better. But the Buddha didn’t knew that. When he hear about it he asked to bring the monks back and taught that monks should not be noisy. This is an occurrence of a Buddha making a “mistake”. And just this kind of mistake he can make, by information he don’t have, which of course, every being will keep making untill their death bed.
I don’t mean to be disrespecful, and obviously I’m not advocating to deny your feelings, but in which base should you trust your feelings/ideas?
Going by your feelings and views is what brought you to this life, again, and it is what been bringing you again to this round of life and death since a beginningless time. To reach wisdom one should unscrew their views, put them to test, every one of them, and get rid of the ones who don’t stand by themselves. The ones you are most afraid to touch are the most important ones. The Buddha’s teachings goes against the grain of the world, including yours.
About your Q&A, I think your post is too wide for this category, but if not:
She became a queen, took revenged, got skinned to death.
But the Buddha prioritized the parents, so in this sense, it could be an utilitarian calculation, to get those 2 out of samsara even if it can cause the their daughter to bear a grudge.
Also from story to Dhp 177, it’s not that the Buddha is careless about his speech, but in that case of the mass offering, he is helping to save the one who would otherwise go to hell, by giving a short Thanksgiving verse, as this time to get the good minister to become enlightened, he can do it without causing the other bad minster to go to hell.
The purpose of redirecting lust is to create more energy toward liberation. It helps to see the body as disgusting in order to do that.
The Buddha, from what I’ve read, spoke in a way that was specific to his audience and surely for a specific purpose. Being that none of us were there and no one here is a perfectly awakened being, it’s difficult to understand the exchange.
I’m a male lay practitioner of Buddhism who still very much appreciates the beauty of the female body. I try to practice a middle way with the subject and not let myself get overly lustful. Really though, I have difficulty believing a beautiful woman’s body is not a living work of art.
The Buddha lived in a different time in a much more spiritual environment and became intensely focused on total liberation of the mind. It is not possible for many in these modern times to have such a focus.
It’s all just head hair, body hair, nails, teeth and skin. If you found any of these just laying around on your bathroom counter, or in your food you’d be rightly disgusted. If you didn’t wash these parts of the body they’d get gross pretty quick. The constant work we have to put in to maintain the illusion that this body isn’t a rotting sack of flesh is a lot, even just at a basic level for monastics.
The suttas were memorized in an oral culture by the monastic sangha for preservation and for their own practice. With the spread of literacy and printing, the suttas became gradually more accessible to laity. With modern technology, anyone can read the suttas if they have access to the internet. The targeted audience is determined by technology and format.
With modern technology, seeing the impurities of the body is less intuitive. Higher standards of living came with better hygiene. Access to fresh water and sewage services is guaranteed to most modern households. Multibillion dollar industry of cosmetics and fragrances sell their products at increasingly affordable prices. When people get sick, they are treated at hospitals - isolated from the public domain. Charnel grounds are illegal in most nations as keeping the body to decompose in the open air is considered a public health hazard - whereas burying or cremating the body are considered more dignifying to the departed. When the COVID pandemic broke out and people anticipated a lockdown, they hurried buying toilet papers. Absence a direct link between the virus and feces, i can’t help but wonder why?
The Itivuttaka was memorised by a lay woman, yet it’s not the fluffy dhamma that some like to think the lay people want to hear. It packs a punch.
Not just kujjutara, but many other lay people in the Buddha’s time memorised the teachings and became liberated. I think it’s not a good idea to say ‘these teaching were for monks only’. These teaching are for anyone who wants to be free.
I did not mean to say that these teachings were for monks only, but i did not envision monks memorizing this sutta to use it to teach laity that marriage is bad because the body is foul. If a lay practitioner want to take more precepts, they are allowed, but for the monastics sangha celibacy is a condition.
As I understand it, the Buddha knew that his teaching on the repulsiveness of the body would help the couple to reflect in the right way and become non-returners. So seeing that they were ripe and had sufficient paramis the teaching was meant for the couple. The Buddha also knew that their daughter Magandiya on the other hand would be offended and holding a grudge against the Buddha would ruin herself.
I guess the other option would have been for the Buddha to withold the teaching from the couple and still reject their daughter in marriage. Their daughter Magandiya could still have resented the Buddha for rejecting her hand in marriage.
I think that Buddhas generally teach prioritising people whose paramis have ripened. Witholding the teaching that could release a person from the rounds of suffering defeats the primary purpose of becoming a buddha.