Copyright for B. Nanamoli, B. Sudhaso, and I.B.Horner

I would be very grateful if someone could help me clarify this :folded_hands:

I’m creating a video for my Buddhist YouTube channel here in the Czech Republic, and I’d like to translate parts of the Mahāsatipaṭṭhāna Sutta into Czech. I know that Bhante Sujato’s translations are published under the CC0 license, so I can freely use them. However, I’m not sure whether the translations by B. Sudhaso, B. Nyaṇamoli and I.B. Horner are also available under CC0. I guess not.

2 Likes

Please look at the individual translations’ copyrights:

Click the info dot.

2 Likes

I did that for B. Sudhaso translation. And this is what i got. It does not say anything about copyright.

1 Like

Huh.

You may need to reach out to the Venerable in that case.

I wonder if @Aminah remembers why there is no copyright listed.

2 Likes

I think you are right. You have poinetd me in the right direction though. Thank you.

2 Likes

Hey! Warm greetings; I hope you are keeping very well!

In short (and by highly fallible memory), the meta data of original sources was applied where it was given and where there wasn’t any (as in this case, see MN10/DN22 Mahāsatipaṭṭhāna Sutta – Bhante Suddhāso) none was sought—of course, permission always was unless the text was explicitly licensed.

2 Likes

Thanks!

So in this case that means that SC has permission to publish (because you received it by asking) but the text itself didn’t come with a copyright notice?

Big thanks for all the work you did to get so many texts uploaded to the site. So much Dhamma Dana!

3 Likes

Aw! That’s really touching and such a lovely reflection to come back from long ago days! :blush: Speaking of reflections: a returned sentiment many times over! You’ve offered and offer so many beautiful Dhamma gifts; thank you so much, Venerable! :folded_hands:

On the point at hand, I could try to dig out old messages, but I hope you’ll forgive me for electing to skip that. In turn, again going by wobbly memory, in this case, I think Bhante @Khemarato.bhikkhu approached me suggesting it might be good to add Bhante Suddhasos’s translations. I have a clearer memory of this in relation to one of the legacy Dhp versions on SC, but I’m a bit more foggy on these translations (perhaps Bhante Khemarato would be so kind as to correct if I am mistaken, and naturally, I offer hearty apologies if I am).

During the time I was taking care of the legacy texts I recall Bhante Suddhaso and I exchanged a few emails, and I’d imagine the first one was asking his permission. If it didn’t happen in this way, then the only other way it would have likely happened is if Bhante Suddhaso himself offered his translations. Some translators did this, but in this case I think I probably asked.

4 Likes

Yes, Bhante Suddhaso is quite approachable online. If you want to use his translations for something, his contact form is here.

The Feldmeier! Yeah, I was quite happy he and you were both game to make that happen :blush:

4 Likes

Phew! :sweat_smile:

3 Likes

He’s got a lot here. I didn’t realize he had that many:

3 Likes

Will they be added to the citation helper? :grin:

3 Likes

That is good to know. Thank you. I seems like Bhante Sujato´s translation will be sufficient for this project of mine. If not, I have a back up plan now:)

2 Likes

I saw that request coming a mile away. I don’t know if he has that many. It would make more sense to me to try and get them on SuttaCentral.

3 Likes

It looks like around 65% them are: Code search results · GitHub

In addition, it seems that some Dhp translations are on SC, but not given on Bhante Suddhaso’s own site (unless I’m not looking in the right place): Code search results · GitHub

3 Likes

Oh wow. Thanks.

Yes, unfortunately the SC interface doesn’t make it obvious how many translations an individual has (I can’t imagine how it would, though). For anyone interested, here they all are:

https://suttacentral.net/search?query=by:suddhaso

5 Likes

You find all translators for a specific language with the number of their translations listed under “languages”. Then each name has a link to the respective search query as posted above for Bhikkhu Suddhaso.

4 Likes

Nice list.

I see that Ven Sudhāso is listed twice- Bhante Suddhāso and Suddhāso Bhikkhu.

sorry to deviate the thread further

eta we also have double ups for John Kelly and Ñ(y)anamoli Thera

5 Likes