What is the meaning of the internal eye in this context MN28, please?
Though the interior eye is intact, so long as exterior sights don’t come into range and there’s no corresponding engagement, there’s no manifestation of the corresponding type of consciousness.
Though the interior eye is intact and exterior sights come into range, so long as there’s no corresponding engagement, there’s no manifestation of the corresponding type of consciousness.
But when the interior eye is intact and exterior sights come into range and there is corresponding engagement, there is the manifestation of the corresponding type of consciousness.
I think here it means the whole optical system, not just an eyeball. In other words, the physical system that enables us to see things.
Second question: how can there be no corresponding engagement?
Does it refer to the Bahiya’s teaching? In the seen, there is only the seen?
I think “internal” here is just emphasizing the relationship to the external sights. I don’t believe it is distinguishing between an “internal eye” and some other kind of eye. So it’s just talking about the organ of seeing in all its usual aspects.
Regarding engagement, think of all the times that our internal sense base exists, and the external object exists, but we simply aren’t paying attention to it. This is, in fact, most of the time.
The internal eye is that-which-allows-you-to-see. It is internal because you can’t access it directly, basically. It is not something you attend to. We can’t see our eyes, and so on.
This is an interesting connection. For the Arahant there is viññana-nirodha, rupa-nirodha and so on (that is why we can’t grasp an Arahant nor the Buddha). So, for an Arahant, in the seen there is only the seen, there is no viññana, vedanā, sañña etc. There is no “I” behind it. So, extrapolating, there is indeed no corresponding engagement, so there is no consciousness, no contact, no feelings etc.
On the other hand, viññana depends on namarupa and namarupa on viññana, so to have viññana there must be attention directed at that sight and intention. When attention is established, that things comes into existence for you through eye consciousness, and that already, simultaneously means contact, vedāna and sañña so that experience is processed.
Based on how we work there is always something more fuzzy and something less fuzzy. When you look at an object, you can also see the space behind it, but less focused. That is still a sight, just a fuzzy sight. When you see what is behind the object, now, the fuzzy sight of the wall, for example, it becomes the object. It wasn’t a different sight, but for you, a fuzzy wall have one existence and a clear wall (the same wall!) now is a clear wall, not a fuzzy wall anymore. So it lands on your consciousness differently.
A group of us spent at least 30 minutes talking about this with Bhante @Sujato and I am far more confused than beforehand. All I can remember is that interior and exterior is like house paint and internal and external is like furniture I am a terrible student!
Agreed. Seeing doesn’t occur without its supporting conditions. A non-exhaustive list of things that have to function adequately for seeing to occur:
The globe of the eye consists of many parts: retina, lens, cornea, etc.
The optic nerve that transmits nervous signals from the eye to the brain
The thalamus, visual cortex, and other brain structures that process those nervous signals
The blood that provides oxygen and fuel, and removes wastes from all those structures
The heart that pumps that blood—without that constant flow, death quickly occurs
The lungs and breathing musculature that inhales oxygen in to the blood and exhales carbon dioxide—again, death quickly occurs without this constant flow
And you could go on and on with more organ systems, getting into more granular detail. And that is just the “internal chain” of conditions in this body. Going further, you can look at “external chain” of conditions like the the oxygen in the air produced by plants and microbes, the food we eat and the liquid we drink, and all the natural and manmade systems that bring those things into existence and keep them going. Break any link in the chain and the whole process falls apart.
Life is precarious, death is certain, and the time of death is uncertain. We are indeed fortunate to have the teaching of a Buddha available and the means to learn and practice it. So let’s keep at it, increasing our efforts over time.