I’ve heard people say that those who give because they want to make merit, are giving for the wrong reasons and that these people are actually making demerit.
I would like to refer to Iti 60 before I start here. Actually, it’s such a short sutta that I’d like to quote it in full:
This was said by the Lord…
“Bhikkhus, there are these three grounds for making merit. What three? The ground for making merit consisting in giving, the ground for making merit consisting in virtue, and the ground for making merit consisting in mind-development. These are the three.”
One should train in deeds of merit
That yield long-lasting happiness:
Generosity, a balanced life,
Developing a loving mind.
By cultivating these three things,
Deeds yielding happiness,
The wise person is reborn in bliss
In an untroubled happy world.
I’ve always understood merit, punna, to literally mean happiness, or if not “literally”, then at least to be the cause of it; a type of action that has the power to facilate happiness. Either way, happiness is what I’ve associated it with.
So 'am I growing the opposite of happiness when I deliberately “make merit”? Are those Buddhists who go and offer dana to the Sangha every single week, because they have a strong confidence in the efficacy of merit making as a means to ensure happiness, simply creating unhappiness because the reason they are giving is because they know or believe that their giving will make them happy?! If they, or I, can’t help giving out of this particular motivation, should they/I stop? Because we’re actually not making merit because it’s coming from a “bad” place.
You might think I’m playing “Mara’s advocate” here.
Well, I am.
I’ve been disturbed to hear people say that if you give just to make merit (to create happiness), you’re making demerit (unhappiness). Surely, those who are making happiness, deliberately knowing what they are doing, with full intention, are actually showing a growth in understanding. They’re actually showing some kind of growth in wisdom about how their minds and hearts work. They’re demonstrating an understanding that making merit, causes their minds and hearts to be happier, their smiles to be broader.
Certainly that’s what I’ve observed. Not just in those who use, to quote the above sutta, the “ground for making merit consisting in giving”, but in those who use the grounds for “making merit consisting in virtue” and “in mind-development”; these people understand about happiness, they look happier, lighter and are generally more open hearted. The fact that they use this understanding to make themselves and the world a happier place does not show their inferiority, it shows that they have a deeper understanding about happiness and suffering than most in this world; and if not an “understanding” as such, at least they’ve adopted a more elegant and effective framework for living their lives.
According to DN 33, the motivations for making merit, giving in this case, are various:
Eight bases of giving gifts:—One gives (1) because [an object of hospitality] has approached; (2) from fear; (3) because ‘he gave to me’; (4) because ‘he will give to me’; (5) because one thinks ‘giving is blessed’; (6) because one thinks ‘I cook; these do not cook; it is not fit that I who cook should give nothing to those who do not cook’; (7) because one thinks: ‘from the giving of this gift by me an excellent report will spread abroad’; (8) because one wishes to adorn and equip one’s heart.
But who are we to observe another’s act of merit making and make prouncements about their motivations?
Playing “mara’s advocate” further: it shouldn’t matter when people judge these merit makers, that the merit makers are traditional Buddhists (whatever that means), but it does seem to make a difference on some occasions at least. It’s almost, from what I’ve observed in some cases, a sort of “soft racism”; or at least, there seems to be an unacknowledged, subconscious subtext to do with ethnicity that seems to be in operation.
If someone wants to make merit, they should never be discouraged. Let them find out for themselves how it makes them feel. The Teachings on what is wiser, more happiness and wisdom inducing, i.e. wholesome, are there to help us encourage each other, not bring each other down.
We all have the capacity to judge and as long as we perceive and live and discriminate, we can’t help it. We have to keep on forgiving ourselves and also others, for not being perfectly spiritual all of the time. It’s a gradual training. The more happiness we all make, the better it is for all of us. Let’s go easy on ourselves and others, if we can; and if we can’t always, we can always promise ourselves to just keep trying and to applaud the successes that we do have; because I’ve noticed that what I focus on, grows bigger.
So in that same way, we can focus on the positive aspects of making merit. I suggest that they far outweigh any perceived negatives.