Discrepancies on the number of bones in exercise #6 from the 9 corpse contemplations.
- B.Sujato has 12 bones in MN 10 english, pali has 13 bones.
- what is the EBT perspective on this?
- AFAIK only AN 6.29 and MN 10 have the 9 corpse contemplations. Can someone confirm?
- in AN 6.29 english, bodhi has 7 bones, and in MN 10, he has 14 bones.
My guess: 7 bones was probably the original,
and the different Theravada sects started adding different number of bones.
I like 7 also because it reminds one of 7 bojjhanga. It also seems to sufficiently cover
the major areas to feel like you contemplated most of your skeleton.
The main reason I ask this is in my translations I’ve been by default going with
whatever sutta central does. But in this case, I’d like to go with whatever is
most likely to be the earliest EBT perspective. So is it the 7?
MN 10 pali from sutta central
Aṭṭhikāni apagatasambandhāni disā vidisā vikkhittāni,
-
aññena hatthaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena pādaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena gopphakaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena jaṅghaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena ūruṭṭhikaṃ
aññena kaṭiṭṭhikaṃ
aññena phāsukaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena piṭṭhiṭṭhikaṃ -
aññena khandhaṭṭhikaṃ
-
aññena gīvaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena hanukaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena dantaṭṭhikaṃ -
aññena sīsakaṭāhaṃ
MN 10 b.sujato english from sutta central
- here a hand-bone,
there a foot-bone,
here a shin-bone,
there a thigh-bone,
here a hip-bone,
there a rib-bone,
here a back-bone,
there an arm-bone,
here a neck-bone,
there a jaw- bone,
here a tooth, - there the skull—
AN 6.29 (pali from sutta central)
1.aññena hatthaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena pādaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena jaṅghaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena ūruṭṭhikaṃ
aññena kaṭiṭṭhikaṃ
aññena phāsukaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena piṭṭhikaṇṭakaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena khandhaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena gīvaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena hanukaṭṭhikaṃ
aññena dantakaṭṭhikaṃ
12. aññena sīsakaṭāhaṃenglish AN 6.29, b.bodhi has 7 bones
disconnected bones scattered in all directions:
here a handbone, there a footbone,
here a shinbone, there a thighbone,
here a hipbone, there a backbone,
and there the skull.english MN 10, b.bodhi
here a hand-bone, there a foot-bone,
here a shin-bone, there a thigh-bone,
here a hip-bone, there a back-bone,
here a rib-bone, there a breast-bone,
here an arm-bone, there a shoulder-bone,
here a neck-bone, there a jaw-bone,
here a tooth, there the skull - here a hand-bone,