Hello everybody! I recently read Seeing with the Eye of Dhamma: The Comprehensive Teaching of Buddhadasa Bhikkhu. It left me with some questions I was hoping someone familiar with the book or the teachings of Buddhadasa could help answer for me.
I’m confused about the difference between the three levels of refuge mentioned in the book, especially the second one, termed superstitious refuge. I assume this is were most converts and adult Buddhists start at out.
Talking about this level the book says:
-
“Those who don’t know how to actually escape dukkha will just follow what others tell them, which is to take refuge in credulous belief—that is, superstitious refuge. This might be fine, when the advice is good. It might be better than not doing anything. If the belief leads to cultivating mind, it’s moving in the right direction. Although still under the umbrella of superstitious belief, people can begin to develop mind in the way of sīla, samādhi, and paññā, if they are told to do that, even if they don’t understand why or how”
-
“The lowest is that based on custom and tradition, which children and people with childlike understanding first meet. Then comes the superstitious level, which involves dependence on something outside of us, which is treated as supreme, a most sacred thing. This will help us, if we surrender to it. This superstitious refuge is based more or less in credulous faith, at least at first. If we believe sufficiently, we will practice accordingly and eventually arrive at the true refuge.”
He also says Buddhism, like most religions, is a gradual path and we start out at a lower level and slowly move towards more realization. He also says “true refuge” is when we clearly recognize the Buddha, Dhamma, and Sangha, which is when he reach stream entry.
- “If less developed, you have the refuge of customs and beliefs that is fairly superstitious. It’s this way in all religions, no matter what their basis. People can’t immediately realize the pinnacle of their religion. They all must make their way gradually, usually depending on others for a while. To reach the highest understanding of their particular system, they have to gradually come to it in this stepwise manner.”
However, at a later section he says:
- “When we take refuge in superstition, we turn the Buddha into a sacred wonder worker and the Sangha into people who take care of us. There’s no self-help in that, no practicing of Dhamma to help ourselves. Such refuge is deviant, a superstitious refuge.”
Doesnt that last quote contradict all of the other ones? How is it deviant when the earlier section says its good and that if we practice we will arrive at true refuge? He also said it’s a gradual path, and that we can’t just jump straight to stream entry and true refuge, so again, how is it deviant? Isn’t this a blatant contradiction?
I’m just really confused about what Buddhadasa is saying, so any info would be appreciated!
Thanks!